2009/945/EC: Commission Decision of 13 July 2009 concerning the reform of the met... (32009D0945)
INHALT
2009/945/EC: Commission Decision of 13 July 2009 concerning the reform of the method by which the RATP pension scheme is financed (State aid C 42/07 (ex N 428/06)) which France is planning to implement in respect of RATP (notified under document C(2009) 5505) (Text with EEA relevance)
- COMMISSION DECISION
- of 13 July 2009
- concerning the reform of the method by which the RATP pension scheme is financed (State aid C 42/07 (ex N 428/06)) which France is planning to implement in respect of RATP
- (notified under document C(2009) 5505)
- (only the French text is authentic)
- (Text with EEA relevance)
- (2009/945/EC)
- 1.
- PROCEDURE
- 2.
- DESCRIPTION OF THE BENEFICIARY
- 3.
- DESCRIPTION OF THE PUBLIC TRANSPORT MARKET IN THE ILE-DE-FRANCE REGION
- 4.
- PROVISIONS OF THE SPECIAL PENSION SCHEME FOR RATP STAFF BEFORE AND AFTER THE NOTIFIED REFORM
- 5.
- FINANCING OF THE PENSION SCHEME FOR RATP STAFF BEFORE AND AFTER THE NOTIFIED REFORM
- 5.1.
- CREATION OF THE RATP STAFF PENSION FUND ON 1 JANUARY 2006
- 5.2.
- THE FINANCIAL AFFILIATION OF BASIC ENTITLEMENTS UNDER THE RATP SPECIAL SCHEME TO STATUTORY SCHEMES
- 6.
- REASONS BEHIND THE ADOPTION OF THE DECISION TO INITIATE THE PROCEDURE
- 7.
- ARGUMENTS MADE BY THE FRENCH AUTHORITIES FOLLOWING THE INITIATING OF THE PROCEDURE
- 8.
- OBSERVATIONS OF INTERESTED PARTIES FOLLOWING THE OPENING OF THE PROCEDURE
- 9.
- COMMENTS OF FRANCE ON THE OBSERVATIONS OF THE INTERESTED PARTIES
- 10.
- SCOPE OF THE PRESENT DECISION
- 11.
- ASSESSMENT OF THE FIRST MEASURE: CREATION OF THE CRP-RATP
- 11.1.
- EXISTENCE OF STATE AID
- 11.1.1. EXISTENCE OF A SELECTIVE ECONOMIC ADVANTAGE IN FAVOUR OF RATP
- 11.1.1.1.
- Absence of an external comparison in the present case
- 11.1.1.2.
- Existence of an economic advantage
- 11.1.1.3.
- Inapplicability of the Combus ruling to the present case
- 11.1.2. INVOLVEMENT OF STATE RESOURCES
- 11.1.3. DISTORTION OF COMPETITION AND ADVERSE EFFECT ON TRADE
- 11.2.
- UNLAWFULNESS OF THE AID
- 11.3.
- COMPATIBILITY OF THE AID WITH THE COMMON MARKET
- 11.4.
- CONCLUSION
- 12.
- ASSESSMENT OF THE SECOND AND THIRD MEASURES
- Article 1
- Article 2
- Article 3
Feedback